Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore Our Properties
Cream stucco home with an arched oak front door, black-framed window, limestone steps, and an autumn grapevine beside a gravel approach.

Windsor CA New Construction vs Resale Homes: Fall 2026 Costs

October 15, 2026

On Sunday, October 11, 2026, five newly built homes on Amanda Way and Tracy Drive in Windsor held open houses from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. All five sit in Ryder Homes' Old Redwood Village, near Old Redwood Highway and Merner Drive. Each is a three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath, two-story house of about 1,870 to 1,890 square feet, priced between $724,990 and $774,990. Several of the listings advertise a rate buydown, a closing-cost credit, or "savings" of more than $40,000 or $50,000.

The price band matters. In September 2026, Windsor's 15 residential resale closings averaged $744,827, according to BAREIS's monthly area report. So a buyer shopping Windsor at that budget this fall can tour an older resale and a brand-new house with a builder subsidy in the same afternoon. Both list prices can land in the same range, but on several of the new homes the builder is also offering to lower the buyer's mortgage rate and cover part of the closing costs.

Windsor slowed down while the county sped up

Countywide, homes are selling faster than a year ago. BAREIS reports that the median Sonoma County residential sale took 43 days on market in September 2026, compared with 53 days in September 2025. Over the same stretch the median sold price rose from $740,000 to $779,500.

Windsor went the other way. Its average days on market was 51 in September 2025 and 75 in September 2026. The monthly figures for 2026 show when the change happened.

Month (2026) Windsor resale closings Average sale price Average days on market
April 22 $1,008,298 39
May 24 $958,072 40
June 24 $828,383 51
July 17 $841,847 44
August 29 $708,594 77
September 15 $744,827 75

Figures come from BAREIS monthly area reports for April, May, June, July, August and September.

These are averages from small samples. One estate sale or one quick flip can move a month's figure. What the table does show is that the slower stretch arrived in the months when Windsor's average sale price fell into the low-to-mid $700,000s. That is the same range where Old Redwood Village prices its homes and where Christopherson Builders' Hummingbird Lane advertises homes "starting at $699K." Nobody has measured whether builder incentives caused the slowdown, and builder sales do not always show up in MLS data. The overlap is still real, and both buyers and sellers in that band are working inside it.

A rate buydown doesn't show up in the price

Two homes can each be listed at about $750,000 and still cost very different amounts to own.

In a rate buydown, the seller pays money up front so the buyer gets a lower mortgage interest rate. Sometimes the lower rate lasts only the first year or two. Sometimes it lasts the life of the loan. The list price stays the same either way, so portals and price-per-square-foot comparisons miss it. A closing-cost credit, like the $10,000 that Ryder advertises on homes such as 159 Amanda Way and 149 Amanda Way, cuts the cash a buyer needs at closing. Builder terms usually depend on conditions such as using a preferred lender and closing by a set date, and the builder's sales office spells those out. That is why a comparison has to rest on actual written terms and not the banner on a website.

A resale seller can do something similar through a seller credit, which a buyer can sometimes put toward a buydown, subject to lender limits. The difference is in who offers first. A builder with seven homes listed as available, several of them ready to move into this month, puts the incentive in the ad before a buyer asks. A resale seller usually offers a credit during negotiation, often after weeks on the market. For a buyer, that gap is room to negotiate. For a seller, it argues for deciding early how to answer a buyer who has a builder's payment quote in hand. Our seller resources go through how credits fit into pricing strategy.

What each option actually hands you

Once the price gap closes, the decision comes down to the physical house. Here is what Old Redwood Village offers, based on its October 2026 inventory page:

  • Two floor plans, about 1,865 to 1,887 square feet, all three bedrooms and 2.5 baths with a two-car garage, all two-story
  • Lots of roughly 2,616 to 3,346 square feet on the listed homes
  • Move-in dates of October 9 and October 16, 2026 on the quick move-in homes
  • A 29-home community in total, according to Ryder's announcement of its July 2025 model opening

Hummingbird Lane, near Robbins Park in southeast Windsor, covers a wider range. Plan 1 is a 1,395-square-foot three-bedroom duet home. Plans 2 and 3 run about 1,942 and 2,075 square feet. Plans 4 and 5 are larger four- and five-bedroom layouts of more than 3,300 square feet. One homesite pairs a house with an attached ADU studio. The builder lists Phase 1, Lots 3 through 11, as selling, with tours by appointment.

A resale in the same price range brings a different set of trade-offs. Lot size, single-story layouts, mature landscaping and an established street are the usual reasons to choose an older house. Age, systems near the end of their life and inspection findings are the usual reasons to hesitate. None of those show up in a list price. The quickest test is to put a resale's lot size and the age of its roof and HVAC next to a new home with a 3,000-square-foot lot and a builder warranty, then ask what the price difference is paying for.

Before signing for either new community, ask about two costs we could not confirm from public sources: whether the homes carry HOA dues, and whether the lots fall within a special tax district. Both change the monthly payment, and both belong in a written answer from the builder. Our buyer guide covers what to request before you go under contract.

Three homes with a separate rulebook

Not every house in Old Redwood Village sells on the open market. In a March 2025 announcement, Ryder said three of its homes would be offered to qualified buyers through the Town of Windsor Inclusionary Housing Program, with Housing Land Trust of Sonoma County as the contact. At the September 16, 2026 Town Council meeting, Housing Land Trust's Housing Director Caitlin Garfield described Old Redwood Village as recently completed and named Hummingbird as an upcoming project, according to the Town's meeting recap.

These homes come from a rule in Windsor's zoning code. For new residential developments of 10 or more units, the code sets inclusionary levels of 10% of units for moderate-income buyers, 7.5% for low-income buyers, or 5% for very-low-income buyers, with owner-occupancy requirements and recorded resale agreements. The code also gives developers other ways to comply, including in-lieu fees, land donation and building the units off-site. Under the land trust model, the buyer owns the house and Housing Land Trust owns the land beneath it through a renewable 99-year ground lease. When the owner sells, the home goes back through the trust at a price set by a resale formula, so it stays affordable for the next qualified buyer. Housing Land Trust accepts applications by email at [email protected] and answers questions at 707-766-8875.

For a market-rate buyer touring the same street, these homes are a separate track and not competing inventory. For a first-time buyer who qualifies, they are a way to own new construction in Windsor at a price set by formula, which matters in a year when even the builder's discounted homes start above $700,000.

Most of the new supply after this will be rentals

Most of the construction coming next to Windsor is rental housing. The Press Democrat reported on September 18, 2026 that Gallaher Community Housing has broken ground on Cora Creek, a 106-unit apartment project at 8975 Conde Lane. Next door, Gallaher's Windsor Creek concept at 8955 Conde Lane has been reduced from as many as 384 units to 245, made up of 35 townhomes and 210 apartments. As of that report, the revision was still at the pre-application stage, with no hearings scheduled.

That means the overlap between new for-sale homes and resales described above comes from a small number of finished homes, and it may not last past the current inventory. Once Old Redwood Village sells out and Hummingbird Lane moves through its phases, Windsor buyers in the $700,000s will be comparing resales against fewer subsidized new builds. Until then, a resale priced as if the builder down the road were not there is priced against the wrong competition.

Questions buyers and sellers raise early

Is Windsor cheaper than Healdsburg or Santa Rosa right now? In September 2026, Windsor's resale average of $744,827 sat far below Healdsburg's $1,628,158 and between Santa Rosa's submarkets. Northwest Santa Rosa averaged $600,162, and northeast Santa Rosa averaged $1,070,536. These are averages from one month, so they work better as a rough guide than as a precise ranking.

Does a slower market mean a Windsor resale will sell for less? Longer days on market usually give buyers more room to ask for credits or repairs. How much room depends on the specific house and on what nearby builders are offering at that moment.

Will the builder incentives still be there next month? Ryder labels at least one offer "limited-time," and the prices here were checked on October 11, 2026. Confirm current terms directly with each builder.

If you're weighing a Windsor resale against a new build, or getting ready to list in a neighborhood where a builder is offering buydowns, Dempsey MacCallum REALTOR® can line up the full cost of each offer side by side. Whitney's title and escrow background helps the credits, fees and closing terms read clearly before you commit. Start with a home valuation or schedule a consultation, and we'll walk through the numbers for your Windsor search.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Follow Us On Instagram