From 2022 through 2025, Petaluma issued zero building permits for structures with two to four units. Over the same four years it permitted 81 accessory dwelling units. Both figures come from the city's own 2025 Housing Element Annual Progress Report, dated May 4, 2026. They matter more this month than they did in May, because Petaluma is about to make the duplex, triplex and fourplex much easier to approve on ordinary residential lots.
On September 14, 2026, the City Council adopted General Plan 2050 in a 6–1 vote. The City of Petaluma's zoning amendments that follow it include a provision allowing four or fewer units on a lot of at least 3,000 square feet in the city's lower-density residential zones. Some listing remarks this fall will probably mention "four-unit potential." The city's own permit history suggests that phrase deserves a discount. Getting permission has rarely been the hard part on Petaluma's small lots. The hard part has been making the numbers work.
What changes on paper, and on what date
The order of events matters, because each step does something different.
- September 14, 2026. Council adopts General Plan 2050 and certifies its environmental impact report, both by 6–1 votes. Councilmember Alex DeCarli cast the only no vote.
- Mid-October 2026. The plan takes effect. The city's General Plan site gives October 15. A September 29 staff report on the zoning amendments gives October 14.
- Late November 2026, expected. The City of Petaluma says Phase 1 of the zoning amendments takes effect 30 days after Council's second reading. This phase contains the four-units-on-a-lot rule for the Rural, Very Low, Low and Diverse Low Density Residential zones.
- June 2027. Phase 2 adoption is scheduled. Staff expect to extend the same pathway to the Mini-Center, Neighborhood Center Mixed Use and Agricultural zones in this phase.
- December 2027 through March 2028. Phase 3, a broader modernization of the code.
The City of Petaluma's Phase 1 draft defines a "Plex" as a building with two, three or four units. Five or more units counts as multifamily. In the Low Density Residential zone, which covers much of the city's single-family housing, the draft allows single-family homes, plexes and townhouses. It sets a density range of 2.6 to 12 units per net acre and a minimum lot area of 2,800 square feet. The four-unit allowance requires a lot of at least 3,000 square feet. All of this is still draft text going through public hearings, so it can change before adoption.
Between the plan taking effect and the zoning catching up, the City Attorney's office issued interim guidance dated August 19, 2026. Housing projects covered by the state Housing Accountability Act can generally rely on the new General Plan's objective standards, such as measurable density ranges, even where older zoning conflicts. Other projects will generally fall under the new zoning once it takes effect, because submitting an application does not by itself lock in the rules in force that day. For a buyer, the practical effect is that a lot's development rules are moving over the next several months. What a seller describes in October may not match the code in force in December.
The permits that state law already allowed
Petaluma's single-family lots have not been locked at one home. California's SB 9, in effect since 2021, already lets owners build a second unit or split a lot in single-family zones. The city's progress reports show how often that happened locally.
| Year | SB 9 units permitted | ADU building permits | 2–4 unit structure permits |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | not reported | 22 | 0 |
| 2024 | 2 | 20 | 0 |
| 2025 | 2 | 27 | 0 |
In 2025, both SB 9 projects were duplexes. Neither was a lot split. The same report shows 59 units in 2–4 unit structures received planning entitlements in 2025, yet none reached a building permit or a certificate of occupancy that year. ADUs went the other way. The city has beaten its Housing Element forecast of about 16 ADU permits a year, and 26 ADUs and JADUs received certificates of occupancy in 2025.
Counts vary somewhat between reports. Petaluma Voice reported 31 ADU permits and 33 certificates for 2025, which differs from the city's table. Under either count, ADUs are the small-scale housing type that has actually been getting built in Petaluma, and the two-to-four-unit building has not.
Why the backyard cottage pencils and the fourplex has not
The city's development fee schedule for fiscal year 2026–27, effective July 1, 2026, explains a good part of that gap.
| Fee | New single-family unit | ADU, unprorated |
|---|---|---|
| Development impact fees, combined | $39,587 | $12,232 |
| Wastewater capacity | $10,292 | $3,788 |
| Water capacity, ¾-inch or 1-inch meter | $5,012 | $5,012 |
The ADU column overstates what many owners actually pay. ADUs under 750 square feet are exempt from development impact fees. One ADU plus one junior ADU added to an existing single-family home is exempt from wastewater capacity fees. A small cottage behind an existing house can avoid most of the city's per-unit charges. A new full unit starts at roughly $39,600 in impact fees alone, before the wastewater and water charges, storm drainage and ordinary permit fees.
Fees are only part of the cost. When the city studied market-rate housing in 2023 for the General Plan, it found that none of its four 3-to-8-story rental prototypes was financially feasible. It traced the gap to high regional construction costs set against Petaluma's lower achievable rents and sale prices, and it estimated total development costs would have to fall 30 to 43 percent for those projects to work. That study is three years old and covered larger buildings than a fourplex, so it is background rather than a current price check. The basic equation it describes still holds. A builder pays Bay Area construction costs and sells or rents at Petaluma prices.
Current prices do not improve that math. The California Association of REALTORS® reported in September 2026 that Sonoma County's median price for existing single-family homes was $790,000 in August 2026. That was down 5.1 percent from a year earlier. Median time on market was 60 days, and the county had 3.7 months of unsold inventory. These are countywide figures, not Petaluma-only figures, and C.A.R. notes that changes in the median can reflect which homes sold. A softer sales market still lowers what a finished small unit can be expected to sell for, which is the side of the equation the city's study found too thin.
Where the plan is betting bigger
The council's debate focused less on backyard fourplexes and more on the denser sites. Station Mixed-Use, the plan's most intensive designation, applies to one parcel. That parcel is 4.48 vacant acres owned by SMART, next to the downtown SMART station. It allows up to 125 dwelling units per acre and up to eight stories, with a floor-area ratio capped at 5.0. Mayor Kevin McDonnell defended the height limit as allowing "creativity and opportunity," and explained that the FAR cap would not permit eight full stories across the entire site. DeCarli had asked for a congestion study and for the earlier height and density limits to be restored in the blocks bounded by East Washington, D Street, Lakeville and Copeland. The council kept the designation. The adoption coverage does not name a private project proposed for the parcel.
The council also made parcel-level changes. It added a mixed-use designation to the Shotwell Auto Body parcel at 213 Cinnabar Avenue and designated the River Park Foundation's property at 500 Hopper Street as Neighborhood Center–Mixed Use. In written comments, Shotwell's owners, Charlene O'Connor and Maurice St. Louis II, asked to keep their existing zoning. Two property owners raised concerns about a proposed minimum of 15 units per acre on their parcel. The new mixed-use designations include minimum densities as well as maximums. A buyer of mixed-use or corridor property should read the new designation as limiting the smallest allowed project as well as permitting a larger one.
Larger projects in Petaluma face their own financing problems. On the east side, the proposed 87-unit Lynch Creek project at North McDowell Boulevard and Lynch Creek Way was reduced from 96 units and was still a proposal as of August 2026. The city's 2025 progress report says Washington Commons was still assembling gap financing a year after it applied. Staff also listed high interest rates and elevated labor and material costs as ongoing uncertainties.
Pricing a lot's potential this fall
A buyer comparing two Petaluma homes on similar 6,000-square-foot lots should weigh them on what can be built and paid for. The rule change makes a second, third or fourth unit easier to approve. Building one still depends on the same economics that produced no 2–4 unit permits over four years. A few questions help separate a real opportunity from a sentence in the listing remarks:
- Which zone is the parcel in, and is that zone in Phase 1? The four-unit pathway reaches Low and Diverse Low Density lots first. Mini-Center, Neighborhood Center and Agricultural parcels wait for Phase 2 in 2027.
- Is the lot at least 3,000 square feet, and does it meet the width and depth minimums? In the Low Density zone, the draft calls for a 40-foot interior lot width and 70 feet of depth.
- What would a small ADU add compared with new full units? The fee schedule strongly favors an ADU under 750 square feet attached to an existing home.
- Has anyone priced construction on this specific site? A rough contractor estimate plus the city's fee schedule will say more than a zoning label does.
None of this is legal, tax or financial advice. The zoning text is a draft, and anyone planning to build should confirm current standards with the City of Petaluma Planning Division before relying on them. Julie's background with properties of up to four units is the experience that applies here; her profile covers it. Our Petaluma neighborhood page and buyer resources cover the rest of a purchase.
A few questions buyers raise early
Does the new General Plan mean every single-family lot in Petaluma now allows four homes? No. The four-unit provision is in the Phase 1 zoning draft, which is expected to take effect in late November 2026. It applies to the Rural, Very Low, Low and Diverse Low Density Residential zones, on lots of at least 3,000 square feet.
If I own a home in Petaluma and plan to sell, does this raise my value? It may make some buyers more interested, but the city's permit record gives no reason to treat added units as built-in value. A home valuation based on recent comparable sales is a better starting point. Our guide to preparing a Petaluma home for sale covers the prep side.
Where can I read the final plan? The City says the final General Plan document will be posted on its website. A user-friendly digital version is expected in spring 2027.
If you're weighing a Petaluma lot with ADU or plex potential and want help sorting the zoning, fees and realistic build costs before you write an offer, Dempsey MacCallum REALTOR® can go through that parcel with you. Schedule a consultation.